The
assassinations at Emanuel A.M.E. Church, followed by the public
forgiveness from the grieving families, were similarly cited by several
South Carolina lawmakers as their reason for voting to remove the flag.
What they are really saying is that Black Deaths Matter, not our lives.
Black people in the US are only deemed worthy of action in their death,
not in their life. In a year that has seen thousands in the streets,
young and old, black white and brown, saying to the nation, “Black Lives
Matter”, the painful and dangerous message coming from South Carolina
this week is: Black Deaths Matter. That’s the painful and dangerous
narrative being developed out of South Carolina; it’s a narrative that
the oppressed of this land have known for a long time: Only Black Deaths
Matter. Our nation is capable of doing the right thing – such as
taking down the Confederate flag in the year 2015, a flag that
represents the racist, immoral, unconstitutional defense of slavery and
Jim Crow – but only when Black deaths happen and are met by a response
deemed acceptable by those in power. Ever since this flag was raised in
1961, to send the message that South Carolina would not honor equal
protection under the law, tens of thousands of small and large protests
have not been enough to move the power brokers to take it down.
SNIP
Taking
down the flag is a good thing. But when we look at the voting and
policy records of most of the political leaders who helped to lower it,
we should be careful with equating its removal as a history-altering
event. Systemic racism is alive and well; they show no intention yet of
dealing with the fundamental inequalities racism still causes in our
society.
But
the power of racism has a strange endurance.
SNIP
Let
us be clear about what's being said: nine Black deaths may get the flag
lowered, but it will not get you one pen to sign Medicaid expansion
throughout the South, which would save thousands of Black lives. Black
deaths will not get full voting rights, which saves Black political
power and produces policies that save black, brown and poor white lives.
It will not get criminal justice reform, which liberates Black lives.
Nor will it get you full funding for public education, a living wage, or
economic empowerment that will lift the lives of black people,
minorities, and the poor. It will not get gun reform. Black deaths only
get you the lowering of a low-down flag that should have never been up.
It will get you nine pens as memorabilia and a signing ceremony at the
Capitol. It will get you one final insult in the promise that an
undignified flag, a symbol of hate, will be lowered “with dignity and
respect” as Governor Haley promised white people still committed to the
Lost Cause. And you will get this only if Black people die, and the
victims’ families and extended family in the human race behave in a
manner declared acceptable and ‘Christian’ by people who have supported
un-Christian, immoral public policy that continues to institutionalize
economic, racial and political inequality.
SNIP
The perpetrator has been caught. But the killers are still at large.
The deep well of American racism and white supremacy that Dylann Roof
drank from remains. The families of the nine martyrs challenged the
schizophrenia of American morality that allowed political leaders to
condemn the crime and at the same time embrace the policies that are its
genesis. Many of South Carolina politicians and others in the nation
are examples. They decry the killings but steadfastly refuse to support
efforts to quell their divisive rhetoric and to cease their push for
policies that promote race-based voter suppression. They refuse to vote
for the Voting Rights Act. They cut funds for public education in ways
that foster, re-segregation. They deny workers living wages. They
refuse Medicaid expansion. They proliferate guns. They use racialized
code words to criticize the president, all in the name of taking ‘their’
country back to ‘prevent its destruction.’ When will they own up to
the fact that there is a history of racialized political rhetoric and
policies that directly spawn the pathology of terroristic assassinations
and carnages, and of violent resistance to constitutional decisions.
If
America is serious about this moment we cannot cry ceremonial tears,
while refusing to support the martyred Pastor and his Parishioners’
stalwart fight against the racism that gave birth to the crime. Gov.
Haley said the people killed in that Charleston church, and the
forgiving actions of their families, set the Confederate flag’s removal
in motion. If that’s the case, then the actions of Black-led protests
don’t matter. Black political power doesn’t matter. Only in the face of
nine Black deaths, and a certain acceptable perceived response, will
anything be done. If this is the standard, how many Black deaths will it
take to secure restoration of the Voting Rights Act, Medicaid
expansion, public education funding, living wages or criminal justice
reform? I shudder to think. This nation needs counseling and redemption
until Black Lives Matters. And when Black Lives Matter, then all lives
will matter. The dehumanization of Black Lives dehumanizes all lives.