Friday, June 12, 2009

The Expert Voice on Health Care Reform

If you want to know what's really going on with health care reform on the ground, among people who live it every day, you can't do better than our good friend Blue Girl.

Decades of working the trenches of emergency medicine in the military give her experience, perspective and insight almost unmatched in the blogosphere. So when Blue Girl says health care workers want single-payer, you better believe it.

There was a meeting yesterday of a House subcommittee where some important things were said by some front-line healthcare providers and medical educators, and although the important things they said were not well reported, I can sum up the testimony in five words...

Healthcare professionals want single payer.

That is because we have had a front-row seat to the horror show that is our current healthcare system and we have come to realize, some of us more quickly than others, that spiraling costs are the biggest problem we face, and the surest, fastest and most effective way to get those costs under control is to move to a single payer system. "Unless you can stop the insurance industry price gouging, we simply cannot make health care affordable, which means you either have price controls on the insurance industry or you take them out of the equation through single-payer reform," said Geri Jenkins, the co-president of the National Nurses Organizing Committee, which represents 86,000 registered nurses. "If we were to have a debate on containing costs, improving quality and universality, the single-payer advantage would be clear."

Walter Tsou, a University of Pennsylvania professor who is an adviser to Physicians for a National Health Program told the panel that for the last 50 years, government policy has protected insurance industry profits at the expense of taxpayers, doctors and hospitals. "Single-payer is the only reform that can control health care costs," he said bluntly. "Our most famous radical document begins with the words, 'We the People.' Not 'We the Insurers.' It is time for our own generation's revolution."

We all know that the single payer discussion is one that we ought to be having, but politicians on every side are scared to death of it, to the point that even though we have a popular Democratic president with strong majorities in both chambers, Democratic legislators took single payer off the table early in the first round of discussions. Unsurprisingly, they regret that decision now. Oops. Probably shouldn't have done that...

SNIP

The bottom line is this: Reform is coming, whether the AMA wants to accept that fact or not, and enough people have realized that every single argument that is made against a public option fails to stand up to scrutiny, because every single negative scenario they point to, patients already have to deal with every time their doctor orders a test, writes a prescription or schedules a procedure - and enough people are independently arriving at this conclusion that 'critical mass' is imminent.

Read the whole thing, or else.

1 comment:

RichMiles said...

There must be some real reason why "everyone is now covered by Medicare" won't work, because even the 4 or 5 sensible and honest Congresscritters out of 535 of them haven't even brought it up yet. You don't suppose it simply hasn't occurred to them yet, do you?

I think that eventually something useful is going to pass this time around, but whether it does or not, the very least that will happen is that there will be a thorough discussion of the cons of the current "system".

You see, speaking of things not occurring to anyone, I honestly don't believe that the overwhelming majority of Americans have ever even done the calculus to realize how much the medical profession, the insurance industry, Big Pharma and our government, elected to serve US not the big money interests, have conspired together to drive prices constantly upward in every way. It's just become a point of gospel truth that health care costs are going to go up, and rapidly, every effin' year.

Let me give you a personal example: I had to have a PET scan recently. The entire procedure took about 30 minutes including prep and getting me into and out of the machine, and the total cost NOT including the physician's fee for interpreting the results ($600) was something over $5900.00. My insurance paid for the bulk of it but not all, but that's actually beside the point of this discussion. Or IS the point of it, if you please.

Now how do they justify that, insurance or no?

The answer is, they don't. They just plug the number into the system and assume everyone will just accept it.

And generally, we do. When was the last time you questioned the cost of a medical or physician procedure in any serious manner?

And this is how the prices keep rising. When we're ill, or suspect we might be, we're disinclined to question anything about the efforts enlisted to help us recover.

And so, the health care industry has us by the short and curlies, and rarely misses a chance to YANK, hard.

Never thought of THAT, didja?