I think a more accurate word is "lynched," but
Matt Taibbi nails it:
We'd
call it murder if a kidnapping victim died of fright during the job. Of
course it's not legally the same thing, but a woman dying of depression
during an illegal detention should be the same kind of crime. It's
especially true given our long and sordid history of overpolicing
misdemeanors.
In
The New Jim Crow,
Michelle Alexander described how white America re-seized control after
slavery by instituting a series of repressive "vagrancy laws," under
which nonwhite Americans could be arrested for such absurdities as
"mischief" and "insulting gestures."
In an eerie precursor to the modern loitering laws, many states even had stringent rules against "
idleness." There were even states where any black male over 18 could be thrown in jail for not carrying around
written proof that he had a job.
What
exactly is the difference between being arrested for "idleness" and
being arrested for "loitering in a designated drug-free zone"? What's
the difference between an arrest for "mischief" and an arrest for
"disorderly conduct" or "refusing to obey a lawful order"? If it's
anything more than a semantic distinction, it's not much more of one.
Law-and-order
types like to lecture black America about how it can avoid getting
killed by "respecting authority" and treating arresting cops like
dangerous dogs or bees.
But while playing
things cool might prevent killings in some instances, it won't stop
police from stopping people without reason, putting their hands on
suspects or jailing people like Bland for infractions that at most would
earn a white guy in a suit a desk ticket. That's not just happening in a
few well-publicized cases a year, but routinely, in hundreds of
thousands or even millions of incidents we never hear of.
That's
why the issue isn't how Sandra Bland died, but why she was stopped and
detained in the first place. It's profiling, sure, but it's even worse
than that. It's a systematic campaign to harass people, using
misdemeanors and violations as battering ram – a campaign that's been
going on forever, and against which there's little defense. When the law
can be stretched to mean almost anything, obeying it is no magic
bullet.
No comments:
Post a Comment